"Are you still with me? We're still gonna do this"

So what do you think , who said it ? Eric or Dylan?

Dylan was laughing and he had time of his life during shooting in library , while Eric was pretty silent ..

"Reb , Ya ready ?" Seems like Dylan was the leader in the library

As far as I know Lisa Kreutz was the only one who claimed that one of them said those words. But if we speculate about this then for me it was Dylan. He always seemed to be checking on Eric and seeing what he was doing. Maybe it was for his own personal affirmation. Eric was more reserved.

Is possible that one of them said so but only one person heard it right? and from the library the witnesses said things that only a couple of people heard and is something that they could heard wrong or misunderstood. We only can speculate then because it could happened but I dont know, this is one of those claims that I put on the list of "conversations from library that supposedly took place but could be a product of the whole chaotic situation"

MysteryMan wrote:

As far as I know Lisa Kreutz was the only one who claimed that one of them said those words. But if we speculate about this then for me it was Dylan. He always seemed to be checking on Eric and seeing what he was doing. Maybe it was for his own personal affirmation. Eric was more reserved.

It was Lisa yes. Her statement is on pg(62) Regarding the comment she says:

Quote :

....she could hear two people coming into the Library. She remembers hearing one of the gunmen say to the other one, "Are you still with me?" and "We're still gonna do this, right?" After entering the Library the gunmen started yelling and moved to the west side of the Library.

It's definitely possible this was said; I remember that the library was most likely in a state of constant noise at that point, and either only one person heard it or only one person bothered to save it to their conscious memory. That said, I could see either of them saying this.