Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.
Columbine High School Massacre Discussion Forum
A place to discuss the Columbine High School Massacre along with other school shootings and crimes. Anyone interested in researching, learning, discussing and debating with us, please come join our community!
Posts : 1338 Contribution Points : 88912 Forum Reputation : 773 Join date : 2016-02-27
Subject: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Sun May 08, 2022 9:52 pm
Anyone have any thoughts or comments on the videos Adam Lanza made? I have a few.
1) I was surprised at how easily he laughed and how often he joked around even though humor did already come across as a big thing for him in his written content. I'll admit I laughed a bunch of times.
2) I was also surprised at how relaxed he sounds when he speaks after hearing the tightly wound radio call years ago.
3) Listening to his suicidal talk could undo five years of therapy if you're also suicidal and have anything in common with him.
4) He pronounces a number of words wrong which I have found to be true more often for people who learn by reading a lot and interact less.
5) He has trouble speaking and expressing himself clearly. You can see it in his writing at times and his speech can be just as garbled.
6) There's nothing psychotic in anything he expressed in his videos but he does say "no comment" when it comes to the schizophrenia online quiz.
Nate22, nrmnfckngrckwll, AlienPenguin, Denethor, alesanagoon and Ak47style like this post
22:22 Banned
Posts : 130 Contribution Points : 28253 Forum Reputation : 162 Join date : 2022-02-01 Location : back on top
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Mon May 09, 2022 1:21 am
I don't know why he spared his YouTube channel when it came to his "digital suicide" I always expected something like that to get deleted by him out of embarrassment such as the 2draw messages that he attempted to delete but couldn't. It was interesting to hear his worries about someone like Nancy possibly listening in on him speaking to himself, you never got to hear much about his paranoia for prison or hospitalization. His bajillion page pedophile essay was a lot easier to sit through when he's actually reading it out. The quiz taking parts were unexpected, but were also some of the more interesting parts to me. It was a nice and personal video collection, there's much more on display in terms of his personality than ever before. What a weird thing to just stumble across, the channel still gets pretty little attention because it was deleted less than 24 hours after being found.
_________________ "Follow me, I follow back."
sscc and QuestionMark like this post
sscc
Posts : 1338 Contribution Points : 88912 Forum Reputation : 773 Join date : 2016-02-27
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Mon May 09, 2022 9:03 pm
I also thought it was interesting that he thought Nancy (because who else could it have been, really) might be listening in on him as he was talking. Supposedly, in the last days before the shooting, she found gory drawings or pictures he'd saved in his room. I wonder if she did resort to spying on him because he was so reclusive and refused to openly communicate his feelings with her.
With the quizzes, it's interesting how he talks about having no friends or family to reach out to for support. He did, at the very least, speak to people online and had one friend in real life and he was honest to a degree, especially with the online friend about his depressive episodes and suicidality, his obsession with pedophilia/pedophobes, and his mass killing obsession. There were people who he could reach out to for support if he ever had the inclination.
I think it's also interesting how he notes that he could be doing anything he wants with his life but he just wants to die. Instead of relating that lack of action to all of the philosophical justifications that he constantly lays out for his viewers, he calls himself a loser because has no job and isn't in school. It's a weird thing to say when you think school is a cultural hellhole torturing young minds into submission. Shouldn't he have been proud of himself for resisting the cultural reward system he was born into? Obviously, he couldn't separate himself from "value" fully while he was alive.
Ak47style likes this post
sscc
Posts : 1338 Contribution Points : 88912 Forum Reputation : 773 Join date : 2016-02-27
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Wed May 11, 2022 12:43 pm
I was thinking this morning about the part where Adam was trying to satirize conservatives with his questionnaire answers and how he brought up survivalists. Maybe a nod to Nancy’s inclinations.
Mr Bubbless Top Contributor
Posts : 485 Contribution Points : 44471 Forum Reputation : 731 Join date : 2021-02-01 Location : STRAYA
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Thu May 12, 2022 7:30 am
sscc wrote:
I was thinking this morning about the part where Adam was trying to satirize conservatives with his questionnaire answers and how he brought up survivalists. Maybe a nod to Nancy’s inclinations.
"Conservatives really piss me off. Actually, everyone does"
_________________ My Blog - mr-bubbless.newtumbl.com
sscc, QuestionMark, Arano, FairyBarf and Ak47style like this post
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Thu May 12, 2022 10:31 pm
On the outside I still can’t believe it happened. I mean, 9 years after the fact, someone finds this channel with practically no views, and puts the pieces together. The feds couldn’t even find it. Did Adam want people to find it? He didn’t delete it like he smashed his hard drive or anything else.
When it comes to the context it’s just baffling comparing the person he is vs all the coverage in the news. The news makes him seem like this sort of alien creature, not quite a human being, but the videos humanize him in a way that makes his actions all the more surreal. It’s really strange to listen to.
Last edited by HollowPointRose on Thu Jun 23, 2022 10:58 pm; edited 1 time in total
sscc
Posts : 1338 Contribution Points : 88912 Forum Reputation : 773 Join date : 2016-02-27
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Fri May 13, 2022 12:20 am
HollowPointRose wrote:
The news makes him seem like this sort of alien creature, not quite a human being, but the videos humanize him in a way that makes his actions all the more surreal. It’s really strange to listen to.
It's funny because I spent years on this forum trying to humanize Adam in a way that I felt was appropriate given the evidence, but it was hard to do with the content that I had available to me - although, maybe it's just a matter of what people want to see. There was always a ton of content available to those who cared to look at it but you're right that this really humanizes him in a way that I never thought possible.
HollowPointRose wrote:
Did Adam want people to find it? He didn’t delete it like he smashed his hard drive or anything else.
I was just trying to figure out if we now have more content than the "Columbiners" (sorry) have available to them and I think we always did have more first hand evidence but now we definitely do. We have hours of Adam in his own words. This is the Sandy Hook Basement Tapes to some degree but not exactly on purpose.
To reply your question, I think the answer is a resounding maybe. I lean toward the idea that he didn't mind if it was found. Similar to the way that he didn't delete any of his posts from around the same time on the forum, maybe this was a statement on who he was, should anyone care enough to look:
At the same time, Adam talks in his videos about killing himself on video, saying people like that sort of thing, and then decides against it because feeling the need to make a statement, to write a manifesto, etc, is against the entire point of what he believes:
"What else can I talk about, that's all that there is to it. It's so stupid, I think, hey why don't I record myself killing myself? People enjoy that. But I'm... doing that would not be recognizing what I'm doing. Still seeking to accomplish something is not saying 'this needs to end'. It's saying 'I need to accomplish something this needs to continue'. I don't really have anything else to say I guess. Whenever someone does have something to say it's because they've hurt theirself, or themself, whatever you grammar Nazis want to tell me. Really, think about it, any time that anyone says anything it's because of a deprivation that has been coerced onto them. X needs to be accomplished, X must be communicated, when you have nothing say, the more silent you are... the closer to death you are. And I always have been silent."
Still, he didn't delete what he recorded. I think he was hoping someone out there would hear it.
QuestionMark, Mirwais500 and 22:22 like this post
Watcher
Posts : 58 Contribution Points : 29598 Forum Reputation : 50 Join date : 2021-11-21
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Mon Jun 20, 2022 12:12 am
I think the audio made me finally understand his motivations. The part where he's against values in themselves... Note how much of his talk was about this or that harming kids. Perhaps his shooting up an elementary school was his ultimate act of self-discipline - overcoming the value of not harming children.
AlienPenguin and justalurker08 like this post
messianic_mania
Posts : 122 Contribution Points : 11550 Forum Reputation : 27 Join date : 2023-12-02
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Wed Jan 10, 2024 5:48 pm
I think the most jarring part of the audios to me was that the way he spoke was incredibly soothing and easy to follow for me... My prefered way of speaking is slow and articulated like he is, I find that my words get jumbled and I'm difficult to follow or understand because I don't want to sound "autistic" by speaking so methodically and slow, it's hard to explain... It's hard to express myself because my thoughts arer so disorganized, so if I actually try to speak with intent to sound well-spoken I end up sounding a lot like Adam. I could tell where his thoughts were going when he was trying to express something complicated but couldn't get it out properly too. Also, him speaking about Travis the chimp on that radio show was something I could easily recognize as "infodumping" about a topic he was clearly well-read on and passionate about. I sound kinda nuts right now though...
It also gave an incredible amount of insight into his motives for the shooting and I think a lot of people take his "philosophy" with a grain of salt in this case, but I believe it's a necessary piece of understanding it. You could put everything together from other people's accounts of him and his online activity and writings and all... And you could definitely understand what got him to the point that he felt how he did about society. Again, me having a lot of similarities to him made it easy for me to understand his frustrations with culture, as autistic people often feel like they don't belong in the world how it is... Nothing is built for disabled people, so we have a lot of frustration with being forced to act "normal" and "fix" the traits that make us abnormal. Adam could have had a similar experience and learned to hate the world he's forced to be in, a world that isn't comfortable for him to be in. I can definitely understand what might bring him to believe what he did, is all I'm trying to say.
Long story short, I think hearing the CultPhil audios was the first thing that made me feel some sort of "connection" or relation to him, in that I saw how similar we are/were in behavior and beliefs and such... Aside from the murder part. But, sorry for the schizo rant.
Koltin, alesanagoon, Arano and Ak47style like this post
ANOMIC
Posts : 2598 Contribution Points : 60913 Forum Reputation : 1394 Join date : 2022-02-22
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Sun May 12, 2024 6:35 pm
Found a comment from a youtuber Lanza talked about in his videos in which he states his reaction: [You must be registered and logged in to see this image.] Video where this came from:
NEXT STEP UP, olof, Vlixu23, Maldoror, ravenwood, bleakplace and bunbun like this post
olof
Posts : 47 Contribution Points : 16977 Forum Reputation : 0 Join date : 2023-01-27
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Tue May 28, 2024 5:18 pm
I once found this blog post and Youtube video linked on a random /pol/ thread. I thought they were insightful and I'd recommending reading or listening to the material if you're at all interested in Adam as an individual. It also made me realize how much of a shame it is that it's so difficult to find non-mainstream coverage of mass shootings on Youtube. It used to be such a pain in the ass for me to find this one Youtube channel, Sandy Hook Facts and it was quite recently and totally by accident that I stumbled upon the video I linked.
bunbun likes this post
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Thu Jul 25, 2024 5:09 pm
I think the videos are definetely very interesting, but what I think is most remarkable is that he doesn't really give a hint for a motive, its just hours of depressive rambling and wanting to commit suicide.
The "saving the kids" at the end feels fake and forced, just to compare himself to his haters and act like a saviour. He didnt really care about kids, he didnt care about anyone, which is why I wonder why he didnt just commit suicide in his room, maybe killing his mother before that yes, but the Sandy Hook shooting seems completely unrelated. If he did it for fame, he would have shared his videos and made a real manifesto, but he even took his brothers ID just to troll the media and make their job of spreading his name even harder lol...
Adam also mentioned the topic of bullying very briefly, like its almost irrelevant to him, and said he can't even remember if he was bullied a single time. That really struck me as odd, with how much he hated culture and the concept of value I would have expected him to hate it because he hates human behaviour toward him, but he never really interacted with ANYONE besides his mother, the DDR guy and with people on this forum, thats why its so hard to understand for me why he hated everything so fucking much without facing any hardship in his life.
I didnt even watch his 8-video pedophile talk, thats boring.
I guess he did the shooting just to kill humans and prevent them from growing up and learning the culture and values he hated so much.
messianic_mania
Posts : 122 Contribution Points : 11550 Forum Reputation : 27 Join date : 2023-12-02
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Thu Jul 25, 2024 8:41 pm
Max2024 wrote:
Adam also mentioned the topic of bullying very briefly, like its almost irrelevant to him, and said he can't even remember if he was bullied a single time. That really struck me as odd, with how much he hated culture and the concept of value I would have expected him to hate it because he hates human behaviour toward him, but he never really interacted with ANYONE besides his mother, the DDR guy and with people on this forum, thats why its so hard to understand for me why he hated everything so fucking much without facing any hardship in his life.
I'll say first that Adam knew he had it easy in life externally - He had money, and the ability to essentially do whatever he wanted. He lived in a huge suburban house with a mother who would do anything - even to her own detriment - to appease him, a mother who also wouldn't stop him from doing things like pinning garbage bags to his windows and sleeping all day and never leaving his room. He mentioned in one note from his computer that he wanted to "try being homeless" because he realized how good he had it and that his privilege might've effected his philosophy [or rather, he said a friend told him so and he knew they were probably right].
But, Internally, his life was quite bad. Everything overstimulated him; he couldn't go an hour without washing his hands, using gloves to touch door knobs, changing/washing all of his clothes etc; he had severe anorexia which if nothing else caused severe health problems for him; and above all else and most importantly he had severe depression that caused him total social isolation even from his own family. It's a miracle he lasted 20 years before attempting taking his own life, or someone elses. He did begin to attempt the Sandy Hook shooting a year or two before it actually happened but Nancy's door was locked so he backed out. I'm an optimistic person, so I'd like to think that if something were different, he could've gotten better and not gone down such a dark path... But I also wonder if he was just doomed from the start to kill himself.
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio Sat Aug 03, 2024 6:57 am
messianic_mania wrote:
Max2024 wrote:
Adam also mentioned the topic of bullying very briefly, like its almost irrelevant to him, and said he can't even remember if he was bullied a single time. That really struck me as odd, with how much he hated culture and the concept of value I would have expected him to hate it because he hates human behaviour toward him, but he never really interacted with ANYONE besides his mother, the DDR guy and with people on this forum, thats why its so hard to understand for me why he hated everything so fucking much without facing any hardship in his life.
I'll say first that Adam knew he had it easy in life externally - He had money, and the ability to essentially do whatever he wanted. He lived in a huge suburban house with a mother who would do anything - even to her own detriment - to appease him, a mother who also wouldn't stop him from doing things like pinning garbage bags to his windows and sleeping all day and never leaving his room. He mentioned in one note from his computer that he wanted to "try being homeless" because he realized how good he had it and that his privilege might've effected his philosophy [or rather, he said a friend told him so and he knew they were probably right].
But, Internally, his life was quite bad. Everything overstimulated him; he couldn't go an hour without washing his hands, using gloves to touch door knobs, changing/washing all of his clothes etc; he had severe anorexia which if nothing else caused severe health problems for him; and above all else and most importantly he had severe depression that caused him total social isolation even from his own family. It's a miracle he lasted 20 years before attempting taking his own life, or someone elses. He did begin to attempt the Sandy Hook shooting a year or two before it actually happened but Nancy's door was locked so he backed out. I'm an optimistic person, so I'd like to think that if something were different, he could've gotten better and not gone down such a dark path... But I also wonder if he was just doomed from the start to kill himself.
Yes thats certainly true...Adams life was a perfect storm for this shooting to happen. So many things could have gone different with another mother, if his father was still at home...I imagine he would have probably looked more closely what his son was doing all day on the computer. Nancy seemed completely slave-like devoted to Adam.
Sponsored content
Subject: Re: Personal Reactions to CulturalPhilistine Audio