Eric vs Dylan in a fight

I know this is a random question but in your opinion, who would have won in a fist fight? Eric or Dylan? I think Dylan because he was 6 foot 3 and Eric was 5 foot 6. So that height difference alone makes me think Dylan would have beat Eric's ass in a fight. What do you guys think?

I think Eric might’ve been a little taller. About 5 feet 9 give or take.

It depends on which Dylan. If you look at his drivers license photo and his RNN interview he was very broad He’s always looked very strong so I’m pretty sure he could kick Eric’s ass. In a mothers reckoning Sue mentions that he was a very strong baseball player but he lacked coordination being so tall and lanky paraphrasing. Plus with the simmering rage I’m pretty sure if Dylan tried to physically fight someone he could probably hold his own.

I assume he was probably pretty weak physically the months before NBK. So I’m not sure how well that Would have worked.

Could go either way but I lean towards Dylan. Dylan has size on his side but Eric got into fights more and knows what it's like.

We should also take into consideration what happened after Eric broke his nose during the massacre.

Draw_It_White wrote:

We should also take into consideration what appened after Eric broke his nose during the massacre.

That he just wanted to commit suicide?

Dylan definitely would have had the height and arm reach advantage, but as ScreamingO said it would have depended on when this fight would have occurred for their weight to have been a factor. Both had explosive tempers, but you can't really discount Eric based solely on his smaller size.

 Like my Granny always said "It's not the size of the dog in the fight, its the size of the fight in the dog"  Now for any non Redneck/non hillbilly-ish folks, that simply means your size means nothing if you know how to fight.

I don't think either had been in what I would consider a real fight. So it's hard to tell who would have won.

Eric was small but he weighed slightly more than Dylan, therefore he was more "solid" than Dylan (even though Eric was far from what you'd consider 'solid').

Eric I think would have won in a fight if Dylan weighed 143 pounds like at the time of the massacre, but if Dylan was 180+ like in 11th grade I think he'd have won hands down.

I think Dylan was the more dangerous of the two as well in terms of mindset come the massacre.

ShadowedGoddess wrote:

Dylan definitely would have had the height and arm reach advantage, but as ScreamingO said it would have depended on when this fight would have occurred for their weight to have been a factor. Both had explosive tempers, but you can't really discount Eric based solely on his smaller size.

 Like my Granny always said "It's not the size of the dog in the fight, its the size of the fight in the dog"  Now for any non Redneck/non hillbilly-ish folks, that simply means your size means nothing if you know how to fight.

I don't think either had been in what I would consider a real fight. So it's hard to tell who would have won.

Good point! If you know how to fight and you know what to do, you can take someone bigger down.

I'm not sure if any of them have a ton of experience. Any altercation with Dylan was mostly yelling and shoving from what I have read and Eric got punched once (and remember it didn't hurt at all)

I imagine a verbal altercation between them would be worse and more intense.

Ivan wrote:

Draw_It_White wrote:

We should also take into consideration what appened after Eric broke his nose during the massacre.

That he just wanted to commit suicide?

Pretty much yeah.