Dylan having second thoughts?

How is there a possibility? You can't ask someone who's doing something when they are going to start doing it.

lasttrain wrote:

How is there a possibility? You can't ask someone who's doing something when they are going to start doing it.

Are you kidding me. Any obstacle that could have paused or set back Eric (maybe his nose, I can't remember at what point this was said), could have lead Dylan to say this. Even if that didn't happen, and even though it is obviously much more likely that Dylan said this, you still can't say for sure how it went down and who said it, because you have NO EVIDENCE. Jesus dude, I don't know how many more different ways I can say it.

eli27 wrote:

It is perhaps illogical, but my point is that it's still possible and you can't prove otherwise. If you can't see that then ... well, you just can't help some people.

To be fair and honest, this is a classic straw man argument. Lasttrain's proposition is logical: Eric said this to Dylan because he fired more rounds outside. You, on the other hand, are attempting to make him prove something that can't possibly be proved: another person's hearsay. That isn't a fair way to argue. Lasttrain made a reasonable point in his original post, but then you went off into la la land when you asked him to prove his point. When he restated his point, you stated that it isn't possibly to ever know. If the proposition is impossible to prove, why make him prove it anyway?