I'm questioning brooks conversation with Eric

Rose The Hat wrote:

"About Brooks - we really have no way of knowing what he knew. He's a known liar so of course he's gonna say he didn't know anything about the shooting even if he did."

How do we know Brooks was a known liar?

Because Brooks has admitted he is a liar. I don't know if you've read this before but this is what Eric said about all the lies Brooks told him.

Eric wrote:

Another BIG example is Brooks Brown. Now, according to him, he has a 215 IQ, 5 other homes (2 in Alaska, and 3 in Florida), 95mph fast ball(he is only 16), runs a mile in about 5 minutes, has an uncle that's the former head of all the armed forces and has access to…..Theee Button…, his other uncle is a multi-millionaire that lives in downtown Detroit, and his neighbors are the chick that sang "r.e.s.p.e.c.t.” and the lead singer of Aerosmith. And that same uncle owns 30% of the stock of that Tylenol company. And his grandparents give..GIVE…him about 1000 dollars for each month, and his other Grandpa can blow up every house in America because all the houses have C-4 in the foundations. Again, according to Brook Brown. OK, when people lie like that, it's not impressive, no one believes it, it sounds just plain stupid, and its a fuckin waste of my time.

Rose The Hat wrote:

Maybe Brooks was just terrified of Eric, therefore he left the school.

Brooks wrote that it was a "gut feeling". Many people would just leave the scene rather than staying stuck in discomfort near somebody whose intentions are not so clear.

sscc wrote:

Mayhem wrote:

Has brooks brown ever spoken about that photo or been asked? Otherwise it's just pure assumption either way, be interested to hear what he has to say about it and why they did that. I actually think he's unreliable with a tendancy to embellish fact after everything ive read and seen about him though.

I don't know if Brooks ever commented on this but I was reading through some documents and I came across something Robyn said about the photo in an FBI interview.

(12272)
ANDERSON regretted posing in CHS senior class picture with KLEBOLD and HARRIS, acting like they were shooting guns. The picture was taken during the second period. They did not talk about posing that way ahead of time. KLEBOLD had put his left arm around ANDERSON and pretended to hold a gun, so she did too.

If it was a spur of the moment thing for Robyn then maybe it was for Zach and Brooks, too.

Brooks mentions it in his book. He says that, Eric and Dylan said they should point finger guns at the camera it would be funny, I'm paraphrasing. He said it was spur of the moment and that the group figured, why not.

How about Judy Brown?

I find myself rolling my eyes when I hear her speak. Especially when she said that she thought Eric was thinking of killing Dylan when he heard he was part Jewish on the basement tapes. At first, it sounds like such an obvious and ridiculous embellishment (and it probably is), but then I thought to myself how much she was right about. And it is understandable that her and Randy would have lost patience years ago and now embellish nearly everything. Their family and their community went through hell. Their reputations were dragged through the mud. They were very close to losing two sons in the massacre.

From their perspective it must be so frustrating. Judy called out Eric to his face, talked to his parents, and tried to work with police in what could have prevented the massacre. A lot of people (some very high profile) weigh in on the massacre with all types of theories and agendas. Seems like Judy Brown is the only one who can wag her finger and say "I told you so."

Part of me wants to say she overreacts. But her dislike and distrust for Eric actually turned out to be correct. She wanted him checked out by authorities, and he went on to attempt mass murder. What are the chances?

runreilly wrote:

How about Judy Brown?  

I find myself rolling my eyes when I hear her speak.  Especially when she said that she thought Eric was thinking of killing Dylan when he heard he was part Jewish on the basement tapes.  At first, it sounds like such an obvious and ridiculous embellishment (and it probably is), but then I thought to myself how much she was right about.  And it is understandable that her and Randy would have lost patience years ago and now embellish nearly everything.  Their family and their community went through hell.  Their reputations were dragged through the mud.  They were very close to losing two sons in the massacre.  

From their perspective it must be so frustrating.  Judy called out Eric to his face, talked to his parents, and tried to work with police in what could have prevented the massacre.  A lot of people (some very high profile) weigh in on the massacre with all types of theories and agendas.  Seems like Judy Brown is the only one who can wag her finger and say "I told you so."  

Part of me wants to say she overreacts.  But her dislike and distrust for Eric actually turned out to be correct.  She wanted him checked out by authorities, and he went on to attempt mass murder.   What are the chances?

The thing that makes me not like Judy is two fold

1) She showed up at the Klebold's house on the day of the massacre. I am sure she tried to make it off like concern but it sure seemed like she was just nosey. Wanting to stick her nose in their business and see what the cops were up to. Even Sue was like wth is this lady here?

2) She was friends with Sue but had a falling out because Judy wanted Sue to speak to the victim's families and apologize to them. Sue disagreed and Judy fought with her over it

Judy thinks she knows best. She also tries to insert herself places she doesn't belong.

Scarletmoon wrote:

Brooks mentions it in his book. He says that, Eric and Dylan said they should point finger guns at the camera it would be funny, I'm paraphrasing. He said it was spur of the moment and that the group figured, why not.

Brooks says it was Eric that suggested it... I don't know...

From No Easy Answers:

THE COLUMBINE HIGH SCHOOL CLASS OF 1999 HAD ITS PICTURE TAKEN on the bleachers of the gymnasium, with close to four hundred kids packed together like one big, happy family. Up in the far left-hand corner of that picture were Eric, Dylan, and me. Zach Heckler and Robyn Anderson were up there with us. We learned we would be doing two different poses: an “ official” or serious class photo and a silly one.

Since he was offering us the chance to do a “ silly” picture, the photographer figured we wouldn't do anything to screw up the serious one. We were instructed to hold still for the extended exposure of the picture, so all of us gave our best “ serious looks” to the camera.

When it came time for the “ silly shot,” Eric donned his KMFDM hat, and he and Dylan both put on shades. Eric suggested that, since we were having a camera pointed at us, it would be cool to point imaginary guns back. So the five of us pantomimed doing exactly that.

It seemed like a funny thing to do. I never thought twice about it. People always ask about warning signs Eric and Dylan might have shown

sororityalpha wrote:

sscc wrote:

I came across something Robyn said about the photo in an FBI interview.

(12272)
ANDERSON regretted posing in CHS senior class picture with KLEBOLD and HARRIS, acting like they were shooting guns. The picture was taken during the second period. They did not talk about posing that way ahead of time. KLEBOLD had put his left arm around ANDERSON and pretended to hold a gun, so she did too.

If it was a spur of the moment thing for Robyn then maybe it was for Zach and Brooks, too.

It doesn't even look like Robyn is pointing guns with her fingers/hand in the photo, does it? Her right arm/hand is around Dylan and her left arm/hand looks like it is down her left side...

Who's that guy in the light blue shirt?

myshame wrote:

Who's that guy in the light blue shirt?

Zachary "Zach" Heckler aka "Kibbz"

myshame wrote:

sororityalpha wrote:

sscc wrote:

I came across something Robyn said about the photo in an FBI interview.

(12272)
ANDERSON regretted posing in CHS senior class picture with KLEBOLD and HARRIS, acting like they were shooting guns. The picture was taken during the second period. They did not talk about posing that way ahead of time. KLEBOLD had put his left arm around ANDERSON and pretended to hold a gun, so she did too.

If it was a spur of the moment thing for Robyn then maybe it was for Zach and Brooks, too.

It doesn't even look like Robyn is pointing guns with her fingers/hand in the photo, does it? Her right arm/hand is around Dylan and her left arm/hand looks like it is down her left side...

Who's that guy in the light blue shirt?

Zach Heckler

Lizpuff wrote:

myshame wrote:

sororityalpha wrote:

sscc wrote:

I came across something Robyn said about the photo in an FBI interview.

(12272)
ANDERSON regretted posing in CHS senior class picture with KLEBOLD and HARRIS, acting like they were shooting guns. The picture was taken during the second period. They did not talk about posing that way ahead of time. KLEBOLD had put his left arm around ANDERSON and pretended to hold a gun, so she did too.

If it was a spur of the moment thing for Robyn then maybe it was for Zach and Brooks, too.

It doesn't even look like Robyn is pointing guns with her fingers/hand in the photo, does it? Her right arm/hand is around Dylan and her left arm/hand looks like it is down her left side...

Who's that guy in the light blue shirt?

Zach Heckler

He looks a lot different with short hair.

I skimmed most of the comments, so I apologise if anything in this comment was already said.

I have my own theory for why Eric told Brooks to leave. I haven't heard anyone present this theory before, so I'm expecting some holes to be poked in it after posting. But Eric wrote in his journal more than once referencing his desire to decide who lives or dies. He even referred​ to the massacre as judgement day on many occasions. I think that may have been a big fantasy for him. Something that he was probably hoping would somehow be realized. I get the feeling it was some sort of power trip or ego boost type of thing.

His conversation with Brooks occurred before the bombs failed, so at that point Eric had no reason to believe the day wouldn't go according to plan. And if it had, in fact, gone according to plan there would have been very few opportunities for Eric to make any decisions about who lived or died. Bombs are not very precise weapons, and shooting people running from a distance doesn't afford many opportunities for descriminating between victims.

I think Eric decided to spare Brooks in that moment. Not because he liked  Brooks (even though he apparently said that was why), or because he felt bad. Simply because by allowing Brooks to escape, he got to play God and decide someone's fate.

I'm​ not saying that he didn't like Brooks, or even that Eric didn't feel bad. But I think that if Eric had run into anyone he knew, and didn't particularly hate, at that moment, he would have spared them too. Regardless of who it was.

I know some people say that it's because shooting him then would have caused suspicion. This is true, but that doesn't explain why he specifically told him to leave. He could have just let him walk back inside and get blown up.

Also, this has probably been said, but regarding the reason why Brooks left just because Eric told him too: I get the feeling that Brooks thought Eric was telling him to get off school property with the cigarette he was smoking. As in "I like you, I don't want you to get in trouble, go smoke that somewhere else".  Brooks did say that after Eric told him to leave he walked off school property with the cigarette and contemplated skipping his next class (something I guess he did frequently). It wasn't until he heard gunshots that he ran home.

sororityalpha wrote:

Brooks Brown encountered Ryan Shwayder, Deanna Shaffer (Ryan Shwayder's girlfriend), and Matthew Houck on 4/20.

Page 007161:

BROWN told them he was going to "the smokers pit", when he saw HARRIS.

Page 006634:

Houck saw Brooks walking down Pierce Street when they first departed from the Columbine Parking lot @ about 11:12am. Encountered Brooks again by Walker Avenue some minutes later.

Page 007130:

Returning from McDonald's saw Brooks standing in the middle of Hoover Street. BROWN told them that he thought he heard shots after he left the school, and that he thought HARRIS was involved. BROWN described that he was outside, and HARRIS walked by him and told him to leave. Then BROWN said, "Oh, man. I think he had a duffel bag with him".

Page 007134:

11:48 Call was made to Matt HOUCK's father at his workplace.
11:51 Attempt by BROWN to call JCSD
11:52 Operator Assisted Call, Call by BROWN to ACSD
11:56 Operator Assisted Call, Call by BROWN to ACSD
12:10 Call by SHWAYDER to his residence
12:10 Call by Deanna SHAFFER to her residence
12:28 Call by Deanna SHAFFER to her residence
12:38 Call by SHWAYDER to his mother on another cell phone

I meant to add this the other day but I forgot. Tony Doty also encountered Brooks that day, just before the shooting. Although the timing might raise questions because it is about 5 minutes earlier than expected, his other times also seem to be 5-10 minutes early (fourth period starts at 10:15, fifth period starts at about 11:05).

(777)
He stated when he returned at about 1105 or 1110 hours, while walking on Pierce Street, Brooks Brown was walking southbound and said hello to him. I asked him if he could identify any of the clothing on Brooks Brown, and he stated he could not, and that he was by himself. He informed me that Brown looked scared, and his complexion was pale.

I find this encounter to be noteworthy because while Houck stated that Brooks was walking slowly as if he had something on his mind, Doty observed that Brooks was visibly disturbed. This supports the idea that Brooks actually left because he suspected that something bad was about to happen and did not just think that Eric was about to pull a senior prank.

Jenn wrote:

Rose The Hat wrote:

"About Brooks - we really have no way of knowing what he knew. He's a known liar so of course he's gonna say he didn't know anything about the shooting even if he did."

How do we know Brooks was a known liar?

Because Brooks has admitted he is a liar. I don't know if you've read this before but this is what Eric said about all the lies Brooks told him.

Eric wrote:

Another BIG example is Brooks Brown. Now, according to him, he has a 215 IQ, 5 other homes (2 in Alaska, and 3 in Florida), 95mph fast ball(he is only 16), runs a mile in about 5 minutes, has an uncle that's the former head of all the armed forces and has access to…..Theee Button…, his other uncle is a multi-millionaire that lives in downtown Detroit, and his neighbors are the chick that sang "r.e.s.p.e.c.t.” and the lead singer of Aerosmith. And that same uncle owns 30% of the stock of that Tylenol company. And his grandparents give..GIVE…him about 1000 dollars for each month, and his other Grandpa can blow up every house in America because all the houses have C-4 in the foundations. Again, according to Brook Brown. OK, when people lie like that, it's not impressive, no one believes it, it sounds just plain stupid, and its a fuckin waste of my time.

No, I haven't read either Eric's or Dylan's writings. I'm not sure if I can.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] thanks for the info:) I'm very new here so it's really nice to jump in disscusion and feel welcomed. I've always wondered about that picture and haven't read brooks brown book. Can't bring myself to line his pockets which he seems to be doing from the massacre. I have this theory on why Eric spared brooks that day (if he actually did) it's pretty powerful to be able to have someone's life or death in your hands. I don't think he spared him because he liked him, or guilt I think he spared him for power. Imagine the feeling for the rest of brooks life knowing hes only alive because "I let you live". I wonder if that is the reasoning for sparing Ethan Todd also. I could be wrong though just a thought

Rose The Hat wrote:

Jenn wrote:

Rose The Hat wrote:

"About Brooks - we really have no way of knowing what he knew. He's a known liar so of course he's gonna say he didn't know anything about the shooting even if he did."

How do we know Brooks was a known liar?

Because Brooks has admitted he is a liar. I don't know if you've read this before but this is what Eric said about all the lies Brooks told him.

Eric wrote:

Another BIG example is Brooks Brown. Now, according to him, he has a 215 IQ, 5 other homes (2 in Alaska, and 3 in Florida), 95mph fast ball(he is only 16), runs a mile in about 5 minutes, has an uncle that's the former head of all the armed forces and has access to…..Theee Button…, his other uncle is a multi-millionaire that lives in downtown Detroit, and his neighbors are the chick that sang "r.e.s.p.e.c.t.” and the lead singer of Aerosmith. And that same uncle owns 30% of the stock of that Tylenol company. And his grandparents give..GIVE…him about 1000 dollars for each month, and his other Grandpa can blow up every house in America because all the houses have C-4 in the foundations. Again, according to Brook Brown. OK, when people lie like that, it's not impressive, no one believes it, it sounds just plain stupid, and its a fuckin waste of my time.

No, I haven't read either Eric's or Dylan's writings. I'm not sure if I can.

If you go to acolumbinesite.com you can find their journals there.

and [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] I have Brooks book and could send it to you in PDF form if you want it without paying for it. LMK

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] I would love a PDF of his book. Thank you:)

Mayhem wrote:

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] I would love a PDF of his book. Thank you:)

I sent you a PM

Rose The Hat wrote:

You have all been so nice to me, and have answered my very specific questions. Please don't ban me for asking this question. Just moderate it and don't post it if you think it goes to far.

You guys have never answered my real question: Did Brooks Brown know more than he admits to? Were his actions really consistent with his story? Did his story change at all? I'm just asking. The reason I ask is because one of the killers asked the other in the library if they were still going through with the plan. I just wonder at the extent of the original plan.

Brooks's story hasn't changed much in the many times he's told it. It's also perfectly consistent with the landscape and geography, as you can see from my post on the first page identifying the green generator he mentions and the underpass.

There is one difference in Brooks's stories, however. According to his book, after leaving class at 11:10 he stood on the sidewalk and Eric pulled up. According to his testimony in the 11k, he walked down to Pierce St and came back when he saw Eric pull in (page 10670). That's a discrepancy.

Jenn wrote:

According to Brooks he saw Eric drive up. If Brooks is telling the truth then he saw Eric the 2nd time he pulled into Columbine, not the first time. He talked to Brooks right around 11:15 and told him to get his ass outta there. Around 4 minutes later, they started shooting. If Brooks was taking his good ole time walking home and smoking a cigarette, he would have definitely heard gunshots. How far can you get in 4 minutes anyway? And that's saying he started walking at 11:15. He probably didn't actually start walking until 11:17 or so.

Brooks says he was walking across the street from a block of housing construction when he heard the first shot.

I've identified these as the homes on W Caley Place, which are listed as having been finished in 2000. This location is about a 3 minute walk from where Eric was parked. So that puts Brooks there right in the 11:17-11:20 window when the shooting starts.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] thank you, I got message but unfortunately I can't reply? Yip happy as to give email just can't send message back

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.], any chance you could send me a copy of that pdf file as well? I enjoyed reading it but, I had borrowed from the library so I don't have a copy on hand.

sororityalpha wrote:

sscc wrote:

I came across something Robyn said about the photo in an FBI interview.

(12272)
ANDERSON regretted posing in CHS senior class picture with KLEBOLD and HARRIS, acting like they were shooting guns. The picture was taken during the second period. They did not talk about posing that way ahead of time. KLEBOLD had put his left arm around ANDERSON and pretended to hold a gun, so she did too.

If it was a spur of the moment thing for Robyn then maybe it was for Zach and Brooks, too.

It doesn't even look like Robyn is pointing guns with her fingers/hand in the photo, does it? Her right arm/hand is around Dylan and her left arm/hand looks like it is down her left side...

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

Wow, I never thought of that. That means either Dylan is pretending to shoot two guns or he is the only one pretending to drive a car.

munchkinphone wrote:

sororityalpha wrote:

sscc wrote:

I came across something Robyn said about the photo in an FBI interview.

(12272)
ANDERSON regretted posing in CHS senior class picture with KLEBOLD and HARRIS, acting like they were shooting guns. The picture was taken during the second period. They did not talk about posing that way ahead of time. KLEBOLD had put his left arm around ANDERSON and pretended to hold a gun, so she did too.

If it was a spur of the moment thing for Robyn then maybe it was for Zach and Brooks, too.

It doesn't even look like Robyn is pointing guns with her fingers/hand in the photo, does it? Her right arm/hand is around Dylan and her left arm/hand looks like it is down her left side...

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

Wow, I never thought of that. That means either Dylan is pretending to shoot two guns or he is the only one pretending to drive a car.

I have never really noticed that either! But the pretending to drive a car comment made me laugh.

I can't see Robyn's other hand either. The hand with the black ring is Dylans. Unless he's holding her hand to make a gun hand, if that makes sense?

It appears she is wearing a white shirt with a black vest on top. If that is the case then her arm is just to low for Dylan to be holding her hand. But it is weird since I feel like I saw someone quote her saying she did it. Maybe there were multiple shots and she did it in another but it didn't get selected.

The way Dylan is wrapping his arm around her and her looking so happy makes me believe it was one of the first shots and then maybe later she joined in. She just looks like I feel I would look if someone I had a crush on randomly put their arm around me. Hahahaa

Munchkin, she DOES have that look. I bet they took a bunch of pictures and Robyn didn't do it in all of them.

munchkinphone wrote:

It appears she is wearing a white shirt with a black vest on top. If that is the case then  her arm is just to low for Dylan to be holding her hand. But it is weird since I feel like I saw someone quote her saying she did it. Maybe there were multiple shots and she did it in another but it didn't get selected.

The way Dylan is wrapping his arm around her and her looking so happy makes me believe it was one of the first shots and then maybe later she joined in. She just looks like I feel I would look if someone I had a crush on randomly put their arm around me. Hahahaa  

I know the silly shot came first. The school thought they could get a better regular photo if they got the silly one done first. We dont know how many copies of each they shot, it sounds like just one of each but you never know

Is there any picture of Robyn in the serious class photo?

munchkinphone wrote:

Is there any picture of Robyn in the serious class photo?

Yes
here
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Lizpuff wrote:

munchkinphone wrote:

Is there any picture of Robyn in the serious class photo?

Yes
here
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Cool, thanks! I am surprised by how many faces I recognize on these photos, some I dont even know why.

Is it Sabrina Cooley sitting next to Kristi? And is that Susan Dewitt in a white sweater?

I cant find Brandi, John Savage or Rachel though.

- Ok, I found John

I know Rachel was a junior and I think John was too!

munchkinphone wrote:

Lizpuff wrote:

munchkinphone wrote:

Is there any picture of Robyn in the serious class photo?

Yes
here
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Cool, thanks! I am surprised by how many faces I recognize on these photos, some I dont even know why.

Is it Sabrina Cooley sitting next to Kristi? And is that Susan Dewitt in a white sweater?

I cant find Brandi, John Savage or Rachel though.

- Ok, I found John

Brandi was a year younger. That was only seniors

I saw John on a list of some class Eric or Dylan was in so I assumed they were the same age and I saw Rachel went with Nick, who is in the photo, to prom so assumed she was the same age as well.

Brandi I could've guessed was younger.

munchkinphone wrote:

Lizpuff wrote:

munchkinphone wrote:

Is there any picture of Robyn in the serious class photo?

Yes
here
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Cool, thanks! I am surprised by how many faces I recognize on these photos, some I dont even know why.

Is it Sabrina Cooley sitting next to Kristi? And is that Susan Dewitt in a white sweater?

I cant find Brandi, John Savage or Rachel though.

- Ok, I found John

Thought you might be interested in this. There was another thread where people pointed out everyone that they recognized.
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

Screamingophelia wrote:

I can't see Robyn's other hand either. The hand with the black ring is Dylans. Unless he's holding her hand to make a gun hand, if that makes sense?

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]


After looking at the pic for a little while this is what I got out of it. To me the red circled area would be Robyn's shoulder. The blue likely her boob. The green where everyone thinks Dylan is holding her hand to me just looks like her throat area where her top buttoned up. If you look at it the other way(Dylan supposedly holding her hand) it would throw her body proportions way off.  What do you guys think?

The green looks like her throat, Dylan has his arm over her shoulder close to her neck.

The red looks like Robyns sleeve and the girl sitting next to her is kind of behind Robyn and leaning into her.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

That's what I see. I don't think Dylan is holding her hand but I do think he's blocking us from seeing the gesture she's making with his own hand. I think the proportions make sense.

But the brown square on her chest is part of her overalls as you can see in the serious class photo, so if she were to hold her arm in front of her we wouldnt see the entire front part of the overalls.

I wasn't sure but I just assumed that it was her hair and I could be wrong. My questions are why so little of the white shirt would be visible near the collar unless it is being covered and why the white shirt is overlapping the top of the overalls if it's not the cuff of her sleeve. Maybe I am envisioning the entire thing incorrectly.

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

Regardless of what people are seeing, Robyn did say that she made a gesture like she was shooting a gun. Why would she say that if one hand was around Dylan's shoulder and the other was down by her side?

sscc wrote:

I wasn't sure but I just assumed that it was her hair and I could be wrong. My questions are why so little of the white shirt would be visible near the collar unless it is being covered and why the white shirt is overlapping the top of the overalls if it's not the cuff of her sleeve. Maybe I am envisioning the entire thing incorrectly.[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

Maybe her overalls shifted upward when she put her arm around Dylan's neck. The overlapping fabric could be where her top wasn't buttoned all the way up.

What is the white thing around the neck of the girl to the right? Maybe that is something and then what [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] circled as Robyns boob really is her arm. Otherwise it seems Robyn has a black line on her sleeve all of a sudden.

munchkinphone wrote:

What is the white thing around the neck of the girl to the right? Maybe that is something and then what [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] circled as Robyns boob really is her arm. Otherwise it seems Robyn has a black line on her sleeve all of a sudden.

I love the fact that here we are having an in depth discussion on the placement of an arm/boob! The picking apart even the tiniest, miniscule details regarding Columbine is weird yet strangely satisfying.

ShadowedGoddess wrote:

munchkinphone wrote:

What is the white thing around the neck of the girl to the right? Maybe that is something and then what [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] circled as Robyns boob really is her arm. Otherwise it seems Robyn has a black line on her sleeve all of a sudden.

I love the fact that here we are having an in depth discussion on the placement of an arm/boob! The picking apart even the tiniest, miniscule details regarding Columbine is weird yet strangely satisfying.

The arm/boob placement is very important
Because if what I thought was her arm is not her arm, then the girl to the right has some weird stuff around her neck

[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.] How do you explain this? What could the stuff circled in blue be?

[You must be registered and logged in to see this image.]

Yeah I'm drawing a blank as to what that could possible be in the blue.

Looks like an apron, or god forbid, OVERALLS!

Maybe Robyn and that girl decided they were both gonna wear overalls and do some fun gesture but then Robyn went to pose with Dylan instead.

Haha I love making up these little stories. Someone has to stop me

Actually it was indeed overalls! If you look close there are a few other girls wearing overalls as well.  Those 90's fashions!

I counted at least 5 girls including Robyn that was rocking overalls. There are possibly more as I just quickly glanced through the pic.

It almost to me still looks like the girl is leaning into Robyn and is wearing a blue top and a white tie.

Screamingophelia wrote:

It almost to me still looks like the girl is leaning into Robyn and is wearing a blue top and a white tie.

The white of whatever it is doesn't seem to be a bright white like Robyn's shirt is. It is more of an off white.

The tie-theory is even better than my overalls-theory.

Now I dont have to worry about why Robyn suddenly has a black line on her sleeve, It's just the other girls right boob. Thanks [You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]